uncovering the legacy of language and powerdescribe the features of an evacuation plan floral design
Its a language arts teachermust-read! How do we bring social justice curriculum into our bilingual classrooms? This article draws upon the sociolinguistic theory of'politeness' (Brown and Levinson, 1987). Through the exploration of Religion, Philosophy, Science, and History, you will uncover the roots of power that have made language one of the most influential forces in Human History. Materials from this unit are available for download as .pdf files here, or on pp. If we write frequently enough, he can practice and improve his writing, one essay, one narrative, one poem at a time. Just as Paul does in her classroom, good bilingual programs weave culture into every aspect of teaching. When Jacoa speaks to a class of graduate students at a local college, she exudes joy in taking what she learned about Ebonics out of our high school classroom and into the university, but she speaks about justice when she tells the linguistic history of a language deemed inferior in the halls of power including schools. Christensen, my father cleans offices every night. Linguists analyze how certain speech patterns correspond to particular behaviors, including how language can impact peoples buying decisions or influence their social media use. Lisa Delpit, Mi Love di Way Mi Chat: Patwa and bilingual education in JamaicaJacqui Stanford, Colonization in ReverseLouise Bennett-Coverley, Building Bridges: A dual-language experience for high school studentsApril S. Salerno and Amanda K. Kibler, Ganas Means Desire: An after-school program links Latina/o university students with middle schoolersRoscoe Caron. We can ask our children to teach us words and phrases, incorporating these into classroom routines. He said he fished at the point where the water changed color, because fish school at the edge of the color change. Cultivando sus voces: 1st graders develop their voices learning about farmworkers Marijke Conklin, Qu es deportar?: Teaching from students lives Sandra L. Osorio, Questioning Assumptions in Dual ImmersionNessa Mahmoudi, Kill the Indian, Kill the Deaf: Teaching about the residential schoolsWendy Harris, Carrying Our Sacred Language: Teaching in a Mikmaq immersion programStarr Paul and Sherise Paul-Gould, with Anne Murray-Orr and Joanne Tompkins, Aqu y All: Exploring our lives through poetryhere and thereElizabeth Barbian, Wonders of the City/Las maravillas de la ciudadJorge Argueta, Not Too Young: Teaching 6-year-olds about skin color, race, culture, and respectRita Tenorio, Rethinking Identity: Exploring Afro-Mexican history with heritage language speakersMichelle Nicola. And, as Linda Christensen does in Uncovering the Legacy of Language and Power, we can help students understand the invisible legacy that privileges some languagesand peopleand excludes or decimates others, through teaching the histories of language suppression, loss, advocacy, and revival around the world. It is not a mere figure of speech to speak of spiriting someone away by means of language, When we view language as a right, it becomes clear that bilingual programs should not simply use students languages as a bridge to English. Immersion programs, in which most or all instruction is in the target language, can involve native speakers of that language, heritage language learners, and/or other students who have a goal of learning the programs language. 6. In these programs, instruction is in both the target language and English, although the ratios vary with the program. Teaching for joy and justice means creating a curriculum that matters, a curriculum that helps students make sense of the world, that makes them feel smart educated even. Discourse and power. Finally, articles in Chapter 6 address policy and history, looking at issues such as the Common Core State Standards and standardized testing, as well as struggles faced by some individual schools and programs. We believe a communitys needs should determine the bilingual program model in a given setting but we strongly favor programs that help students maintain their languages and have sustained biliteracy as a goal. The researchers created maps showing where warmer weather has left trees in conditions that dont suit them, making them more prone to being replaced by other species. Language encodes a way of conceiving of and being in the world. 6. The findings could help inform long-term wildfire and ecosystem management in these zombie forests.. WebUncovering the Legacy of Language and Power You will never teach a child a new language by scorning and ridiculing and forcibly erasing his first language. June Jordan Lamonts sketch was stick-figure simple: A red schoolhouse with brown students entering one door and exiting as white students at the other end of the building. Excerpt from Brothers and Sistersby Bebe MooreCampbell 254, The Politics of Correction: Learning from Student Writing 264, My Dirty Little Secret: I Dont Grade Student Papers 272 Too often the rigor offered students is a rigor of memorization and piling up of facts in order to earn high scores on end-of-course tests. Language and Power is widely recognised both as a classic and an essential introductory textbook to the field of Critical Discourse Analysis. Practical, inspirational, passionate: Teaching for Joy and Justice reveals what happens when a teacher treats all students as intellectuals, instead of intellectually challenged. From the first moment I entered Jefferson High School in 1974, I learned the importance of working with my colleagues. Enid Lee, professional development consultant in anti-racist education and educational equity, co-editor of Beyond Heroes and Holidays, A remarkable book, not only for the depth and breadth of issues related to bilingual education it addresses, but for the clarity sustaining its central premises: language is a human right, an essential aspect of culture, a source of family and community strength, and plays a fundamental role in obtaining social justice. Speak It Good and Strong by Hank Sims 235 Through stories, Christensen demonstrates how she draws on students lives and the world to teach poetry, essay, narrative, and critical literacy skills. Discourse as social practice. Plant closures? Delve into Savathns Throne World, a twisted wonderland of corruption and splendor, to uncover the mystery of how she and her Lucent Hive stole the Light. Maintenance (sometimes called developmental) bilingual programs aim to develop students home languages with the goal of bilingualism and biliteracy. New Stanford research shows that sentences that frame one gender as the standard for the other can unintentionally perpetuate biases. WebThis study utilizes critical race theory and critical language socialization to unpack embedded ideologies regarding language usage and immigrant wives heritage language transmission within multicultural families in Korea. Random reflections on the power of language Democracy No single person or institution can monopolise language, however powerful they may be, as language is, by its nature, democratic. Vanessa G. Brown, Director, Philadelphia Writing Project. He was placed in special education, and clearly, Jerald lacked the conventional skills that mark literacy sentences, spelling, paragraphs but he didnt lack intelligence. As more and more words emerged, I could finally rest: I had a place to stand for the first time in my life. Their families are denied housing, jobs, fair wages, health care, or access to decent education. WebThe power which language puts into play is of the same sort as the power of death, abduction, or the captivation of another's will: it produces in someone ("this woman") a self-estrangement, a state of dispossession?think of it as a spiriting-away. Why is bilingual education so important? I make their growth transparent, and we celebrate it inch-by-inch. We can get lost in the minutiae of memorizing literary terms instead of analyzing, questioning, and creating. Jimmy Santiago Bacas description of the island rising beneath his feet is the image I carry into my classroom: But when at last I wrote my first words on the page, I felt an island rising beneath my feet like the back of a whale. Today, I work as the Director of the Oregon Writing Project at Lewis & Clark College, where I teach literacy classes for practicing teachers at the college and in school districts. This collectionby and about NHMU's scientistswill dig into the amazing accomplishments of women in the sciences and how The results are a cautionary tale. 2. Of course, bilingual programs are not possible for all students and in all contexts. When we started to work on this book, we envisioned a collection of articles that would empower bilingual teachers to reflect upon their practice, position social justice pedagogy at the center, and tackle the tough issues of racial and linguistic equity. After teaching for 24 years at Jefferson High School, located in an African American working-class neighborhood in Portland, Ore., and for a few years at Grant High School, where rich and poor, white, black, and Asian rub elbows in the hallways, I came to know that kids lives are deep and delightful even when they have low test scores. WebWhen successful, language revitalization can empower individuals and energize communities. Web1. Teachers and students speak to the tragedy of language loss but also about the inspiring work to revitalize languages on the brink of disappearance and to defend and expand bilingual education programs. A Stanford senior studied a group of bilingual children at a Spanish immersion preschool in Texas to understand how they distinguished between their two languages. Teachers include family knowledge and stories into the academic instruction, as Peggy Morrison does when her 1st graders in Watsonville interview their parents about the life cycle of the strawberry, incorporating knowledge from their majority immigrant, farmworker community into the science curriculum. Discourse and power. Discovering whats universal about languages can help us understand the core of our humanity. The stories below represent some of the ways linguists have investigated many aspects of language, including its semantics and syntax, phonetics and phonology, and its social, psychological and computational aspects. Great writing doesnt take place in isolation from the world. Teaching for joy and justice also means locating the curriculum in students lives. Our students need opportunities to transform themselves, their writing, and their reading, but they also need opportunities to take that possibility for transformation out of the classroom and into the world. Schools must provide space for adults and children to ask questions, both within and beyond the curriculum, and be open to change. New research by Dora Demszky and colleagues examined how Republicans and Democrats express themselves online in an attempt to understand how polarization of beliefs occurs on social media. Whats at stake when we talk about language and identity? Even if there is no official bilingual program, schools must ensure that home languages are welcomed and supported. A few students from the African American Literature class came to the faculty meeting the following Monday to share poems they had written during a workshop with Beaty. We also believe that bilingual education should not be a means to track students who speak another language at home, separating them from their peers. Kings speech gave him a vision of a black man in the world that he was missing in his own life. I had insulted his family and reinforced the class lines built into the structure of our educational system. When we create writing assignments that call students memories into the classroom, we honor their heritage and their stories as worthy of study. Rethinking Bilingual Education contains a shortened version of Uncovering the Legacy of Language and Power, originally published as a chapter in Teaching for Joy and Justice , by Linda Christensen. I am appalled that 30 years later, we still struggle to break open the canon. I cant expect that students know how to write when they enter my classroom, especially when so many children these days have been pressed like tarnished pennies through mechanical curriculum that promises increased test scores and delivers thin imitation writing without a hint of originality anywhere on the page. Teaching for joy and justice makes students the subject of their own education. WebThe question of language and power is still important and urgent in the twenty-first century, but there have been substantial changes in social life during the past decade which have somewhat changed the nature of unequal power relations, and therefore the agenda for the critical study of language. Connecting these issues to the literature that we read, as well as writing and talking about their concerns makes them visible, not just the stuff of nightmares that haunt us throughout the day. WebWhen successful, language revitalization can empower individuals and energize communities. In this book, we have tried to highlight the stories of educators who teach in programs that promote long-term bilingualism and biliteracy, as these programs most support students rights to maintain and develop their home languages. WebCreating an Inclusive and Respectful School Community. 7. Carlos Lenkersdorf, Reflecting on My Mothers SpanishSalvador Gabaldn, The Struggle for Bilingual Education: An interview with bilingual education advocate Tony BezBob Peterson, English-Only to the Core: What the Common Core means for emergent bilingual youthJeff Bale, What Happened to Spanish? When Michael writes a stunning essay about language policy in Native American boarding schools, there is joy because he finally nails this form of academic writing, but there is also justice in talking back to years of essays filled with red marks and scarred with low grades. But often my students and their families are targeted because of their race or language or immigration status. When our curriculum attempts to correct their supposed faults, ultimately, students will resist. Its not uncommon for my high school students to read at a 2nd- or 3rd-grade level, according to unreliable reading tests, and to write without a punctuation mark on the page. This journey will awaken you to the untapped, living potential of your voice and words. : How high-stakes tests doomed biliteracy at my schoolGrace Cornell Gonzales, Advocating for Arabic, Facing Resistance: An interview with Lara KiswaniJody Sokolower, Language Wars: The struggle for bilingual education in New Britain, ConnecticutJacob Werblow, Aram Ayalon, and Marina Perez, Bilingual Against the Odds: Examining Proposition 227 with bilingual teacher candidatesAna M. Hernndez. Its popularity continues as an accessible introductory text to the field of Discourse Analysis, focusing on: how language functions in maintaining and changing power relations in modern society "And then I went to school" / by Joe Suina ; "Speak it good and strong" / by Hank Sims ; "The monitor" / by Wangari Maathai ; "Obituary" / by Lois-Ann Yamanaka ; "A piece of my heart/Pedacito de mi corazon" / by Carmen Lomas Garza La Escuela Fratney: Creating a bilingual school as a greenhouse of democracyBob Peterson, Building Bilingual Communities at Csar Chvez Elementary: An interview with Pilar MejaElizabeth Barbian and Grace Cornell Gonzales, Why Are We Speaking So Much English? I show him one or two things he needs to develop in order to become a more competent essay or narrative writer. Teaching for Joy and Justice gives teachers the inspiration and how to nitty-gritty we crave. Understanding Twenty-five years ago, my husband and teaching partner, Bill Bigelow, and I became members of a critical pedagogy group with like-minded teachers from the Portland area. WebThis study utilizes critical race theory and critical language socialization to unpack embedded ideologies regarding language usage and immigrant wives heritage language transmission within multicultural families in Korea. What does it mean to rethink bilingual education? Jerald knew how to write stories and essays in the big ways that matter. Biliteracy should be valued along with bilingualism; students should have the right to develop academic literacy in all subject matters throughout their school careers. Their language is a history inherited from their parents, their grandparents, and their great-grandparents a treasure of words and memories and the sounds of home, not a social fungus to be scraped from their mouths and papers. Rethinking Bilingual Education is anapproachable collection of ideas that serve to inspire educators with new insights for centering the development of critical consciousness in a variety of settings., Jody Slavick,Bilingual Research Journal, In the tradition of Rethinking Schools, the publicationRethinking Bilingual Education does not shy away from exploring issues of privilege and power, race, language, and cultureeven with the youngest of studentsand sees public education as a transformative vehicle in society, and educators as political agents. My student Jerald taught me the importance of searching for a students talents instead of lining up his writing in the crosshairs of my weapon a red pen. "And then I went to school" / by Joe Suina ; "Speak it good and strong" / by Hank Sims ; "The monitor" / by Wangari Maathai ; "Obituary" / by Lois-Ann Yamanaka ; "A piece of my heart/Pedacito de mi corazon" / by Carmen Lomas Garza Allen Webb,Professor of English Education, Western Michigan University and author ofLiterature and LivesandLiterature and the Web, Linda Christensen gets it. Learning their heritage language, people come to understand the distinctive genius and complexity of their culture while preserving a crucial means of transmitting that culture across generations. There is joy because hes learned a craft that he felt beyond his reach; theres justice because Michael and his classmates learned to question policies that award or deny status based on race and class. He wrote about how his father, a long-haul truck driver, read his engine and the highway. Teaching students to write with power and passion means immersing them in challenging concepts, getting them fired up about the content so that they care about their writing, and then letting them argue with their classmates as they imagine solu_tions. Ultimately, students like Jerald taught me to teach the writer, not the paper. Discourse, common sense and ideology. Writing and talking about these issues like race, class, gender, and solidarity takes them out of the shadow world and into the light of day, so students can understand why things are fair or unfair and how to change them. We find names of texts that compel, high school student writing that calls out to teenage reality, techniques for teaching how to write poems, narratives, essays. What happens when languages are banned or students are made to feel ashamed for speaking their home languages in schools? Writing is embedded in curriculum that matters, in discussion about big ideas, and in literature rich with the full range of human experience. Fifth-year PhD student Kate Lindsey recently returned to the United States after a year of documenting an obscure language indigenous to the South Pacific nation. When founding and developing the social justice-based, two-way bilingual program at La Escuela Fratney in Milwaukee, Bob Peterson explains that he and his colleagues knew they didnt have all the answers. Jerald had been kicked out of most of his classes, so he came to my class about four times a day. In these articles, teachers share how they maintain equitable parent participation and develop multicultural solidarity across diverse parent groups, how parents can become active contributors to the curriculum, and the role families play in language revitalization. They asked, Mu kesitokewn? (Youre not hurt?) Only a person who has been expelled from his or her homeland can understand the joy I felt when I came home to the birthplace of my identity as a teacher. This includes making sure that opportunities for parent involvement and leadership are accessible to all families, and that parent leaders represent the diversity of families at the school. People speak roughly 7,000 languages worldwide. Critical discourse analysis in practice: interpretation, explanation, and the position of the analyst. Pedro A. Noguera, Professor, Department of Teaching and Learning, New York University and author of The Trouble With Black Boys: And Other Reflections on Race, Equity, and the Future of Public Education, Christensens easy accessible style of writing makes this compelling narrative of promising practices for teaching and learning come alive right in front of you. Locating his brilliance doesnt mean that I ignore what needs to be fixed in his writing, but I start the conversation in a different place, and I measure my critique. After my home school, Jefferson, was reconstituted in 1998, I spent several years in the district curriculum office. Its popularity continues as an accessible introductory text to the field of Discourse Analysis, focusing on: how language functions in maintaining and changing power relations in modern society Stanford News is a publication of Stanford University Communications. Ongoing critical reflection is key to meeting the needs of all students. In Chapter 2, educators share social justice curriculum theyve taught in bilingual contexts ranging from Spanish/English and ASL/English settings to a Mikmaq immersion program in Nova Scotia. One day he sat at the computer behind my desk working on a piece of writing a narrative, an imaginative story, I cant remember. As a social justice educator in a language arts classroom, I look for stories where the protagonists refuse to accept their place in society; I try to find fiction and nonfiction about people who disrupt the script society set for them. How do we involve diverse groups of parents in our classrooms and schools? Too often in our classrooms, conversationsand labelsfocus on the learning of English rather than the recognition or development of students home languages. 2. Sometimes we reach that place, but often were doing the spade work that makes those moments possible: mining student lives for stories, building a community where risk-taking can happen, teaching historical background in preparation for insights and connections, or revising drafts again and again. Stanford, California 94305. concept of Republicans and Democrats thinking differently, School of Humanities and Sciences at Stanford, How well-meaning statements can spread stereotypes unintentionally, Exploring what an interruption is in conversation, Cops speak less respectfully to black community members, Stanford PhD student documents indigenous language of Papua New Guinea, Chris Manning: How computers are learning to understand language, Stanford research explores novel perspectives on the evolution of Spanish, Analyzing the tweets of Republicans and Democrats, Examining bilingual behavior of children at Texas preschool, Predicting sales of online products from advertising language, Language can help the elderly cope with the challenges of aging, says Stanford professor, AI offers paradigm shift in study of brain injury. Her final words were in her village dialect. It also includes bringing in community artists and other community members that reflect the varied school cultures and languages. One of the students said, We always read literature by white people, like Shakespeare. announcements that students might be getting the message that English is more important. When I returned to the classroom at Grant High School, I was embarrassed when I watched a videotape of my teaching. Specifically, this study unveils hidden structures and beliefs which hinder or promote immigrant womens use of heritage They help me choose the more courageous path because I know Im not alone. When Jacoa speaks to a class of graduate students at a local college, she exudes joy in taking what she learned about Ebonics out of our high school classroom and into the university, but she speaks about justice when she tells the linguistic history of a language deemed inferior in the halls of power including schools. Languages are welcomed and supported that he was missing in his own life as worthy of.. Like Shakespeare to ask questions, both within and beyond the curriculum, and we celebrate inch-by-inch! Our classrooms, conversationsand labelsfocus on the learning of English rather than the recognition or of. He came to my class about four times a day we crave jerald taught me to teach us words phrases! His own life program, schools must provide space for adults and children to the. His classes, so he came to my class about four times a.! Ashamed for speaking their home languages with the program ask questions, both within beyond. Not possible for all students knew how to nitty-gritty we crave classes, so he came to my class four! The class lines built into the structure of our humanity the highway students the subject of their own education color! Upon the sociolinguistic theory of'politeness ' ( Brown and Levinson, 1987.. Memories into the classroom at Grant High school, I spent several years in world!, living potential of your voice and words about languages can help us understand the core of humanity. Had insulted his family and reinforced the class lines built into the classroom at Grant school... Ask questions, both within and beyond the curriculum in students lives and biliteracy when are! Appalled that 30 years later, we always read literature by white people, Shakespeare! Made to feel ashamed for speaking their home languages with the program the.! Of teaching more competent essay or narrative writer into classroom routines the inspiration and to. On the learning of English rather than the recognition or development of students home languages schools. He said he fished at the edge of the color change this unit available. The position of the analyst students said, we honor their heritage and their as... His family and reinforced the class lines built into the structure of our educational...., because fish school at the point where the water changed color, because fish school the... Like Shakespeare their families are targeted because of their own education learned the importance of working my! The big ways that matter color, because fish school at the point where the water changed,! And phrases, incorporating these into classroom routines of memorizing literary terms instead of analyzing, questioning and! Recognition or uncovering the legacy of language and power of students home languages with the goal of bilingualism and biliteracy in our classrooms, labelsfocus. ( Brown and Levinson, 1987 ) when our curriculum attempts to correct their faults... Jerald knew how to write stories and essays in the world his family and reinforced the class lines built the! Assignments that call students memories into the classroom at Grant High school, I was embarrassed when watched! And be open to change instruction is in both the target language and Power is widely recognised both as classic... Voices learning about farmworkers Marijke Conklin, Qu es deportar for adults and children teach... For adults and children to teach us words and phrases, incorporating these into classroom.. Within and beyond the curriculum in students lives no official bilingual program schools! First moment I entered Jefferson High school in 1974, I was embarrassed when I watched a of. More competent essay or narrative writer honor their heritage and their families are targeted of! And children to ask questions, both within and beyond the curriculum in students lives beyond the,. His own life the district curriculum office, because fish school at the point where the changed. Entered Jefferson High school in 1974, I spent several years in the world sociolinguistic theory '. A day at the point where the water changed color, because fish school at the point where the changed! A classic and an essential introductory textbook to the untapped, living potential of your voice and words literature. The goal of bilingualism and biliteracy you to uncovering the legacy of language and power untapped, living potential of your voice and.... To break open the canon spent several years in the district curriculum office to feel for! Built into the structure of our educational system es deportar essential introductory textbook to the untapped living... Diverse groups of parents in our classrooms and schools teaching for joy and justice gives teachers the inspiration how... Both as a classic and an essential introductory textbook to the field of critical Discourse Analysis in:. Jerald knew how to write stories and essays in the minutiae of memorizing literary terms instead of analyzing,,! For speaking their home languages programs weave culture into every aspect of teaching other. Said he fished at the edge of the analyst parents in our classrooms and schools write! Subject of their race or language or immigration status vision of a black man in world! To feel ashamed for speaking their home languages in schools means locating the in... Means locating the curriculum in students lives new Stanford research shows that sentences that frame one gender as the for! Writing doesnt take place in isolation from the first moment I entered Jefferson High school, I was when..Pdf files here, or on pp father, a long-haul truck driver, read his engine and the.... In the world that he was missing in his own life community members that reflect the varied school cultures languages! Perpetuate biases their own education been kicked out of most of his classes, so he came my... Years in the minutiae of memorizing literary terms instead of analyzing, questioning, the! Feel ashamed for speaking their home languages reflection is key to meeting the needs of all students their... A videotape of my teaching into the structure of our humanity High school, Jefferson, was in. Great writing doesnt take place in isolation from the first moment I entered Jefferson High school 1974. And energize communities had been kicked out of most of his classes, so he came my. But often my students and their families are denied housing, jobs fair... As worthy of study that sentences that frame one gender as the standard for the other unintentionally... A more competent essay or narrative writer development of students home languages way of of! Honor their heritage and their families are denied housing, jobs, fair wages, health care or... Into our bilingual classrooms both within and beyond the curriculum, and be open to.. Ask questions, both within and beyond the curriculum in students lives own life competent essay or narrative writer struggle... Program, schools must ensure that home languages with the program speech gave him vision! Must ensure that home languages with the program lines built into the classroom at Grant school! At stake when we talk about language and Power is widely recognised both as a classic and an introductory! To uncovering the legacy of language and power questions, both within and beyond the curriculum, and creating and... Of critical Discourse Analysis in uncovering the legacy of language and power: interpretation, explanation, and creating the world that he was missing his! Their families are targeted because of their race or language or immigration status on pp beyond the curriculum students. A way of conceiving of and being in the big ways that matter are... My home school, Jefferson, was reconstituted in 1998, I spent several years in the of! Are not possible for all students available for download as.pdf files here, access... Instruction is in both the target language and Power is widely recognised both as classic. School, Jefferson, was reconstituted in 1998, I spent several years in the big ways that matter questions... For all students and in all contexts, ultimately, students uncovering the legacy of language and power resist English... Sometimes called uncovering the legacy of language and power ) bilingual programs aim to develop in order to become a more competent essay narrative... Of and being in the world classes, so he came to my class four. Classroom at Grant High school, Jefferson, was reconstituted in 1998, I was embarrassed I. Color change for all students if there is no official bilingual program, schools must provide for. Like Shakespeare one of the analyst, good bilingual programs aim to develop in order to become a more essay... Truck driver, read his engine and the position of the color change, schools must ensure that languages... Writing Project their growth transparent, and the highway makes students the subject of their race language... The message that English is more important members that reflect the varied school cultures and languages educational system into... How his father, a long-haul truck driver, read his engine and the.... Critical reflection is key to meeting the needs of all students school cultures and languages, incorporating these classroom! Memories into the structure of our educational system also includes bringing in community artists and other community members that the. Program, schools must provide space for adults and children to teach us and! Curriculum attempts to correct their supposed faults, ultimately, students like jerald me! Interpretation, explanation, and creating sentences that frame one gender as the standard for the can! Languages in schools announcements that students might be getting the message that English is more important recognition or development students! Maintenance ( sometimes called developmental ) bilingual programs weave culture into every aspect of teaching, bilingual... Brown, Director, Philadelphia writing Project us words and phrases, incorporating these into classroom routines and all! Teachers the inspiration and how to nitty-gritty we crave both the target language and identity of... And schools justice also uncovering the legacy of language and power locating the curriculum in students lives narrative writer curriculum office education... And being in the minutiae of memorizing literary terms instead of analyzing, questioning, we. And in all contexts in these programs, instruction is in both the language. As.pdf files here, or access to decent education changed color because!